Skip to content

Schedule a free 30-minute consultation Book a time

Nobody in the Coalition Room Works for You

Shirline Wilson Shirline Wilson 9 min read

First in Same Table, Different Stories, a series on coalition work and influencing without position authority — what it takes to get organizations moving in the same direction when no one can make anyone do anything.

The first thing to understand about coalition work is that you cannot make anyone do anything.

There is a table of interested people with varying position authority inside their own organizations. They hold titles that mean a great deal inside their own walls and often much less at the coalition table. Outside of convening staff or facilitators, no one reports to anyone. No one can be assigned a task, held to a deadline, put on a plan, or overruled on anything they haven’t explicitly volunteered for. Everyone is there by choice, which is another way of saying everyone can leave.

So here is the question worth sitting with before the next meeting: if nobody at your table has to be there, what is actually holding them?

I have spent twenty years in rooms like these — education policy tables, advocacy campaigns, employer coalitions, and in service of boards and committees. What people had most in common in those rooms was an interest in a shared vision: justice, fairness, some kind of progress for people who were not being served well. The rooms could not have been less alike. The dynamics were nearly identical every time, and the lesson that took longest to sink in is that the absence of authority is not a defect in how these groups are made up. It is its own organizational dynamic, and it needs the right structure to perform well. The thing that makes this work slow, that makes progress hard to see from one quarter to the next, is the very same thing that makes it durable. When people cannot be compelled, whatever they do together is something they chose. That choice is the only asset a coalition has. It has to be earned again at every meeting.

Which changes what leadership looks like at the coalition table.

Leadership here looks like naming clear roles, responsibilities, a charter, and performance expectations

In a room without position authority, the convener’s job is not to be the decider. It is to facilitate decisions that stay consistent with the shared vision and the outcomes the group agreed to when it formed — and, before that, to make sure those things have actually been written down, because a coalition with no charter is a coalition where ambiguity resolves toward whoever is most comfortable talking and most willing to stay late.

Every coalition meeting also contains a fact that everyone knows and no one has spoken. Two member organizations quietly stopped submitting their numbers. A commitment that was easy to sign in a good year has become expensive in a hard one. Someone’s public statement last month made three people at the table uncomfortable and none of them intend to mention it. The meeting can run pleasantly for ninety minutes without touching any of it. Most meetings do.

The convener’s other job is to put the unspoken fact in the middle of the table in a form people can pick up rather than flinch from. Not as an accusation. As a description. Half of you haven’t sent your data this quarter, and I don’t think it’s because you forgot. Can we talk about what changed? That sentence, in its hundred variations, is most of the work. It is also the point at which a coalition becomes useful or becomes a standing meeting that produces a newsletter.

Courage is the currency of shared progress

In healthy coalitions, courage gets spent on approach, tactics, and language — almost never on what it looks like to get to the goal. Everyone signs up for the goal. The disagreements that matter are about how, how fast, who does it, and what we call success on the things we can control.

Courage in this work rarely looks like a lecture, or rumination on who has power and who doesn’t, and it never looks like taking and keeping the moral high ground. It looks like sharing your actual opinion, offering feedback someone can act on, being curious about a perspective you don’t share, and staying at the table when the group goes a direction you argued against.

It is easy to mistake participation for progress. The member who objects in ways that stop movement without offering a path forward. The camera that stays off, they stay quiet in voice and in the chat window. The concern that never surfaces in the meeting and circulates afterward in twos and threes, or along a faction, or in a quiet word to the funder that the policy everyone endorsed will not survive the session. None of that is courage. It is the shape courage takes when the room has become expensive.

The real acts look different. The vice president who goes back and tells her CEO the company is behind its peers. The superintendent who agrees to a reporting standard his own team is going to resent him for. The executive who says, in front of direct competitors, we tried that and it didn’t work, or everyone is afraid of backlash or blow back.

Nearly all of those acts happen after the meeting ends, out of sight, in rooms without the full group. The honest measure of a convening is not how candid the conversation felt while it was happening. It’s did you represent your honest feelings and opinions in the context in the meeting so that they can be discussed, clarified and negotiated in the room where it mattered?

You cannot demand that people show up ready to work. A good facilitator puts the tools on the table to make it more possible to make progress towards a coalition objective — We do this by making sure the person who goes first is not punished for going first, we meet candor with recognition rather than advantage, and by being visibly willing to dive into the uncomfortable conversations with clarity and integrity. We also know when something needs to take a bit more time to get to agreement, and help a convener see that, and adjust their expectations accordingly.

Emotional intelligence is not niceness. It is a critical working tool.

This is the part that gets misread most often. In a room of peers, emotional intelligence (EQ) is not warmth, smoothing or comforting when you are doing it right. It is a tour through the uncomfortable world of human relations. Mastery here is picking up the skills essential to improving coalition performance, where diverse experiences and ideas intersect.

Having EQ skills helps you spot which silence is agreement and which is dissent. It tells you that the person pushing hardest on process is usually protecting something they haven’t named — a nervous board, a legal review that went badly, a team that’s exhausted at feeling like they can never get it right. It tells you whose yes, means yes, and not just going along to get along. Getting that last one wrong is how coalitions end up either with commitments on paper and nothing that moves or stuck altogether – we call these phenomena motion over movement.

And EQ skills help you with the harder half of how you show up in coalitions you may be leading or convening: how you manage yourself. Do you become defensive when your ideas are challenged, and then do you decide either the facilitation or the room is broken because your ideas were not the winning ones of the day? How do you regulating your own reactions — when someone questions your idea or premise, or when a member disengages publicly, when the work you built gets described as a nice-to-have, and not mission strategic. Do you get stuck from meeting to meeting because you didn’t have a quorum of the right folks tracking and following along so that a decision can be made and progress moves to the next step. The essential skills of EQ include Self-Awareness, Self-Regulation, Internal Motivation, Empathy, Social Skills.

Different stories, and reasons for joining, with one purpose

Coalitions rarely stall over whether the goal is the right goal. They get stuck because people arrive to the project carrying very different reasons for being there and are disconnected from what it will take to get to the goal they all think is a great idea.

One member joined because their board asked them to volunteer. One because they are working on building their network, context or access to a room or table where decisions may get made. Sometimes it’s because a peer leader made a personal ask over dinner. One has been doing this work for twenty years and is tired of working for a cause they deeply care about but feel exhausted, compassion fatigued or burnt out, and needs someone else to care as they do, so they can take a break.

Building a shared purpose once the table is set, requires understanding more of the story about each person’s why and how they are connected to the goal. The strong start involves making sure there is enough overlap in the stories around the table connected to the goal that meaningful progress can be made. That overlap is almost always smaller than the founding language we assume everyone is signed on to. Understanding where interest intersects is a far stronger foundation, because every person can recognize their own reason inside it.

Helpful tip to try at your next coalition retreat. Have each member write down, the reason they believe they are actually there — not the reason in the charter. Then, at the meeting, ask them. The gap between your two lists is important work to do to prepare for a high performing coalition.

Getting a group to uncover their real shared purpose takes a bit of time to periodically uncover, is occasionally uncomfortable, but well worth it to keep and get a coalition unstuck, or off on the right foot. You are priming members to name what’s true for them, and assists you in the important discipline to read a room accurately, and demonstrate the patience to let a purpose be built from what people actually want to get out of the coalition experience rather than the aspirations in a charter that they may or may not have contributed to. The distance between a commitment and its consequence is made almost entirely of the areas of intersectional alignment.

Nobody in the coalition room works for you. What are they choosing by coming to the table, can you spot the intersections of shared interest, and what would it take for participants to show up authentically aligned to their interests in pursuit of the coalition goal?

Next in this series: structure is what you have instead of authority — the agreements worth writing down before you need them, and why a room where nobody disagrees is a room that has quietly left.

Convergent Strategic Consulting helps coalitions, partnerships, and leadership teams move from stated commitment to real consequence. If you’re convening a group that has the right people and not yet the right traction, book 30 minutes with me.

Schedule a conversation

Share this article
Keep reading

more from field notes.

Leadership · Partnerships · Organizational Effectiveness

sometimes the next step issimply a conversation.

If you're navigating complexity, stakeholder alignment, leadership challenges, or organizational change, we'd welcome the opportunity to learn more about your work.